This is the story of the Great Wallaroo Land Swindle of 1882 — the “Manhattan Purchase” of Australian sport. Only instead of trading glass beads and trinkets, the famous Arnold bothers of Wallaroo bought all of Queensland for Rugby using nothing more forceful than Zig Zag Railway tickets and liberal bumpers of champagne.
Everyone under either Rugby code in Australia should thank Wallaroo FC for this one.
Sweet Notes from Victoria
Back in 1880, buoyed by their first Victoria vs South Australia inter-colonial contest under Victorian Rules, the Victorian Football Association (VFA) sent letters north to the Southern RFU (NSWRU). They waved grand proposals of cross-code matches on the SCG—promising they would lead to “national unity” in football rules.
Wallaroo captain Richard Arnold stood as firm as Sydney sandstone against the idea. As a powerful executive within the Southern RFU, he declared the notion of playing back-to-back matches under alternating codes “almost frivolous”. Arnold knew each colony would simply win under its own rules. On the field, it would breed nothing but bickering and bad blood—a repeat of the Carlton-Waratah contests of 1877 and ’78 that had only entrenched each side’s established views.
While Arnold was envious that the VFA had successfully launched inter-colonial games first, he declared there was a better alternative. He had his eyes looking across the sea. Judging from letters he received from the New Zealand colony, they were staying loyal to Rugby, and from the specimens of Maoriland footballers he had already encountered, a New South Wales team would soon find a foe worthy of their steel.
A year on, there was still no inter-colonial Rugby, and the Sydney football landscape had been splintered. There now were a handful of Melbourne-rules clubs and a NSW Football Association (NSWFA), which publicly stated one of its objects was inter-colonial matches with Victoria.
This news caught the attention of Brisbane FC captain, Pring Roberts.
Queensland on the Fence
Over the 1870s, Queensland footballers were flip-flop flounces; one year they played Melbourne-rules, the next good ol’ Rugby. When Roberts arrived at Brisbane FC in 1875, Rugby was the dominant game. Over the next few seasons, local newspapers recorded his deeds as a footballer who thrived on drop goals, long solo runs, running in tries, and other Rugby intricacies.
But by the early 1880s, Brisbane FC, Brisbane Wallaroos and the other clubs and all the schools had fallen head over heels in love with the Melbourne game once more. For the 1882 season, just three out of twenty matches were scheduled under Rugby rules. It looked highly probable that the whole colony was about to go over, body and soul, to the bouncers.
That would have left NSW entirely isolated. Very soon, it likely would have sent the alternative history of Rugby in Australia down the darkest alleys of Little Lon, never to be seen or heard from again.
The Lost Letter
In July 1881, Roberts wrote a letter to the Melbourne-rules NSWFA in Sydney, politely enquiring what inducements they might offer for his Brisbane team to visit the Harbour City. By a twist of fate, that innocent letter stayed trapped in a dark corner of the Sydney GPO. It did not see daylight again until it was finally unearthed at a NSWFA meeting in May 1882.
By then, however, the NSWFA was preoccupied with arranging a grand tour for Geelong FC, one of Victoria’s hot-shot Melbourne-rules clubs. With their attention divided, all they offered Roberts in reply was a distant, lukewarm “perhaps next year.”
The Wallaroos Smell Opportunity
The story of the lost letter and the NSWFA’s snub soon leaked into the Sydney newspapers. It immediately caught the eyes of Richard Arnold and his brother, fellow Wallaroo stalwart William ‘Monty’ Arnold. Monty was a master of the diplomatic pen. He pounced on the opportunity.
Without any discussion before a NSWRU meeting, the Wallaroo wrote to Roberts offering the earth. Monty said the city’s Rugby men would enthusiastically welcome a team and the NSWRU would bankroll every last expense: steamer fares, premier lodgings, and boundless colonial hospitality besides. All the Wallaroo in his letter asked in return was that the visitors come as an official, representative Queensland team—and play exclusively under Rugby rules. This would be an inter-colonial tour.
When it did all come up at a NSWRU meeting chaired by Richard Arnold, the Arnolds cover story was awry about which club they were dealing with, but nevertheless said Wallaroo FC had received “letters…from Mr. Pring Roberts, of the Wallaroo Football Club, Brisbane, challenging the Sydney Wallaroo Club.” By then though the terms of the offer and its generous conditions were with Roberts to dwell upon.
Champagne, Zig Zags, and a Bargain
At first, Roberts tried to be fair to his Melbourne-rules footballer colleagues in Brisbane. After all, they were in the majority. So he went back to the NSWFA offering a dual-code tour from a Queensland team. They weren’t interested unless everything was played under their rules, though they did eventually sweeten the pot with fifty percent of the gate money. It was a poor offer compared to the Wallaroos’ open-handed bargain.
Things moved quickly after that. At a meeting of Brisbane clubs, Roberts stunned all when he announced he had telegraphed the NSWRU accepting the all-expenses-paid Rugby tour. To seal the deal, Monty Arnold had laid out exactly what “generous colonial hospitality” meant not only the obligatory gala harbour cruise, but an end-of-tour banquet, a grand ride up the Blue Mountains on the famous Zig Zag Railway, and a river of champagne that would never run dry.
For The Colony’s Sake!
At that news the outcry in Brisbane triggered more headlines than the following year’s Krakatoa eruption. It was an absolute sell-out! Outraged traditionalists flooded the press, claiming the bait was taken “ostensibly for no other purpose than that of sensual gratification.” Critics slammed negotiators who risked the colony’s football reputation just to secure “the enjoyment of the many pleasures held out,” forcing men to play a game they knew absolutely nothing about. Worst of all, the organiser was branded as having “strong Rugby tendencies”—as if it were a contagious social disease.
The tour committee shut down the moral panic with cold arithmetic: the recent Geelong tour had just lost £150 because Sydney spectators flatly refused to pay for Melbourne-rules. Faced with an NSWRU offer too grand to counter, the critics soon wore themselves out, with one bitterly spitting out a final, sarcastic defeat: “The terms have been unconditionally accepted. A glorious time of it anticipated. What more do we want?”
It Was All Fun Proper, All In A Proper Spirit
Seventeen Queenslanders, including Roberts, duly arrived in August aboard the steamer Leichhardt. for what turned out to a six-match visit. Met at the wharf and loaded into four-in-hand drags, they were whisked off to the Metropolitan Hotel like visiting royalty. That very evening, with champagne flowing freely, Richard Arnold rose to propose a toast to the visitors. He declared this the first-ever intercolonial match under Rugby rules in the colony, hoping it would become an annual tradition. “Hear, hear!”
Off the field, the real conquest took place. The Queenslanders were treated to the glorious Blue Mountains railway trip—though they were so utterly wearied by non-stop hospitality that they never actually made it to the famous Zig Zag. Monty Arnold also hosted a grand harbour cruise, but the crown jewel was the end-of-tour banquet. There, Monty delivered a razor-sharp, humorous speech skewering the newspapers for praising the Melbourne game while running down Rugby, leaving the room ringing with laughter.
On the field, the first Queensland XV turned out in Brisbane FC jerseys of red and black hoops. As expected they were beaten in their two matches against navy-blue NSW combinations, but stunned everyone with their quality. Even the NSW skipper, Wallaroo’s James Brodie, declared the opening clash the finest display of Rugby football he had ever witnessed.
In a hilarious twist, the Queenslanders managed a glorious SCG victory over the Wallaroos themselves the day after the banquet. The result left many wondering if the hosts had ignored their own “early to bed” orders. The irony was thicker than the harbour winter fog!
The Payoff
The Queenslanders sailed home as full converts. Roberts “professed to play Melbourne Association, and tries to play Rugby, but he confessed to his being a complete convert to Rugby” now. Captain Hickson thanked their hosts warmly, declaring every member of the team deeply gratified by the lavish hospitality.
Just two weeks after the visitors sailed out of the Heads to ply northwards home, a 19-man NSW party followed them out, only they turned south-east toward Auckland. Over a month they played seven Rugby games in New Zealand.
The following year, 1883, the deal was sealed for good. A representative NSW team sailed north, managed by none other than Monty Arnold himself. The crowds for those matches were the largest ever seen for any outdoor sport in Queensland. The tide became a flood. Within a few weeks, the Northern Rugby Union (QRU) was born. By the end of the 1880s, the Melbourne-rules game in the north had withered and died out completely. Extinct.
A Masterclass of Colonial Diplomacy
As told in the newspapers, when the 1883 NSW team’s steamer approached Brisbane at dawn, the local footballers, including members of the first Queensland team, could just make out a tall figure standing at the bow. They quickly saw it was Monty Arnold, wearing the satisfied smirk of a man who had dined very well indeed.
The native wallaroo doesn’t dine out on Victorian mice — but this Marsupial surely did!
[ site homepage ]
